Available 24/7
phone icon
833-635-COMP

Can You Get a Second Medical Opinion During an OWCP Claim?

November 10, 2026

OWCP Claims

Federal employees who suffer workplace injuries often depend on the Office of Workers' Compensation Programs (OWCP) to cover medical treatment and provide wage-loss benefits. However, disagreements can arise over the severity of an injury, the treatment required, or whether an employee is capable of returning to work.

If you disagree with a medical evaluation during your OWCP claim, you may wonder whether you have the right to obtain a second medical opinion. Under the Federal Employees' Compensation Act (FECA), federal workers may have opportunities to obtain additional medical evaluations, although the procedures depend on who requests the examination and why it is needed.

For federal employees in Metairie, New Orleans, and throughout Louisiana, understanding these rules can help protect access to appropriate medical care and workers' compensation benefits.

Can You Request a Second Medical Opinion in an OWCP Case?

Yes. Federal employees may seek additional medical opinions during an OWCP claim, but there are important distinctions between requesting an evaluation from another physician and undergoing a formal second opinion examination arranged by OWCP.

Under FECA, injured federal employees generally have the right to select their initial treating physician, subject to applicable program requirements.

If you disagree with your physician's diagnosis or treatment recommendations, you may seek additional medical advice. However, changing your authorized treating physician generally requires OWCP approval, and obtaining reimbursement for additional treatment may depend on authorization requirements.

A formal OWCP second opinion examination is different. Under 5 U.S.C. Section 8123, OWCP may require an injured employee to undergo an examination by a physician it selects when additional medical evidence is necessary.

Understanding which type of evaluation is involved is essential because each follows different procedures.

Why Would OWCP Request a Second Medical Opinion?

OWCP may arrange a second opinion examination when it needs additional information about an employee's medical condition or eligibility for benefits.

These examinations are commonly used when the agency needs clarification about:

  • Whether the diagnosed condition is related to the workplace injury.
  • Whether additional medical treatment is necessary.
  • Whether the employee remains temporarily disabled.
  • Whether the employee can return to work with restrictions.
  • Whether a permanent impairment exists.
  • Whether the medical evidence supports continued wage-loss compensation.

For example, a federal employee in Metairie may receive treatment for a back injury and remain unable to perform regular job duties.

If OWCP questions whether the employee can return to work, it may arrange an examination with another physician to evaluate the employee's current limitations.

The resulting medical report may influence future benefit decisions.

Do You Have to Attend an OWCP Second Opinion Examination?

Generally, yes. When OWCP properly directs an employee to attend a medical examination under FECA, the employee is expected to cooperate.

Under 5 U.S.C. Section 8123(d), refusing or obstructing a required examination can result in suspension of compensation until the refusal or obstruction stops.

This makes it important to take examination notices seriously.

Before attending, injured employees should review the appointment information and understand the purpose of the evaluation.

During the examination, it is helpful to:

  • Explain symptoms accurately and consistently.
  • Describe how the injury affects daily activities.
  • Discuss relevant medical treatment and restrictions.
  • Provide an accurate medical history.
  • Avoid exaggerating or minimizing physical limitations.

If a legitimate scheduling conflict or medical concern prevents attendance, contact OWCP promptly rather than simply missing the appointment.

What Happens if the Second Opinion Doctor Disagrees With Your Physician?

Disagreements between physicians can create complications in an OWCP claim.

For example, your treating physician may conclude that you remain unable to work, while the OWCP second opinion physician believes you can return to modified duties.

When medical opinions conflict, OWCP must evaluate the evidence according to applicable FECA requirements.

The agency may consider several factors, including:

  • Whether the physician reviewed the relevant medical records.
  • The thoroughness of the examination.
  • Whether the physician provided a reasoned medical explanation.
  • The physician's qualifications and specialty.
  • Whether the conclusions are supported by objective findings.

A disagreement does not automatically mean that OWCP must accept the opinion of its selected physician.

When an actual conflict exists between the employee's physician and the physician examining the employee for the government, FECA provides a process for obtaining an impartial medical examination.

What Is an Impartial Medical Examination Under FECA?

An impartial medical examination, sometimes called a referee examination, may be necessary when opposing medical opinions create a qualifying conflict.

Under 5 U.S.C. Section 8123(a), when the employee's physician and the government's physician disagree, OWCP must appoint a third physician to resolve the conflict.

This physician is intended to provide an independent medical assessment.

The impartial examiner may be asked to address issues such as the employee's diagnosis, disability status, work restrictions, or need for further treatment.

A properly supported impartial medical opinion may receive special weight when OWCP determines the claim.

However, the report must still satisfy applicable medical evidence standards.

Federal employees should understand that an impartial examination is not automatically required whenever two doctors express different opinions. The disagreement must meet the requirements for a genuine medical conflict.

Can You Change Your Treating Doctor During an OWCP Claim?

Federal employees generally have an initial choice of physician under FECA, but changing treating physicians after that selection is subject to OWCP rules.

An employee may request authorization to change doctors for legitimate reasons, including concerns about treatment availability, relocation, or the need for specialized medical care.

However, switching physicians without following the applicable procedures can create problems with treatment authorization and reimbursement.

For example, a federal employee in Metairie who requires specialized orthopedic care may need to request approval before transferring ongoing treatment to another physician.

It is important to distinguish between obtaining a consultation and formally changing the physician responsible for managing an accepted workplace injury.

Our Metairie OWCP attorney can help federal employees understand medical evidence requirements, physician changes, and disputes involving OWCP benefit determinations.

Can a Second Medical Opinion Affect Your OWCP Benefits?

Yes. Medical evaluations can significantly influence whether OWCP approves, continues, modifies, or terminates certain benefits.

For example, a second opinion report may address whether an employee:

  • Remains unable to perform regular job duties.
  • Can return to limited or modified work.
  • Requires additional medical treatment.
  • Has reached maximum medical improvement.
  • Has a permanent impairment related to the accepted injury.

If OWCP determines that the medical evidence supports a change in benefits, it must follow applicable legal and procedural requirements.

Employees may have opportunities to submit additional evidence or challenge adverse decisions through FECA's administrative review procedures.

The appropriate response depends on the decision issued and the deadlines involved.

How Can an OWCP Attorney Help With Medical Disputes?

Medical disagreements can be especially difficult when they affect an employee's ability to receive treatment or wage-loss compensation.

An attorney familiar with federal workers' compensation can review the medical evidence, identify potential conflicts, and explain the procedures available for challenging unfavorable determinations.

Legal assistance may involve evaluating physician reports, preparing supporting documentation, and addressing disputes concerning disability or treatment authorization.

For injured federal employees in Metairie and surrounding Louisiana communities, understanding the difference between an additional medical consultation, an OWCP second opinion examination, and an impartial examination can help prevent avoidable mistakes.

Contact Our Metairie OWCP Attorney

A second medical opinion can play an important role in a federal workers' compensation claim, particularly when physicians disagree about the severity of an injury, treatment needs, or the ability to return to work.

At Sarphie Law, we assist injured federal employees in Metairie, New Orleans, and throughout Louisiana with OWCP claims and related benefit disputes.

If you are experiencing medical disagreements or difficulties with your OWCP claim, our firm is here to help. Call us today or connect with us online to schedule a consultation.

Contact Us

Get in touch for a case review

red line

Get In Touch

Copyright © 2025 Sarphie Law - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by:
Epic Web Results Logo
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram